... Andy Zophy: The best brisket sandwich in Portland along w hush puppies n alot of beer choices. Explore best places to eat melt sandwich in Portland, Maine and nearby. However, I now love my Italian sandwiches from little Eddie’s Variety Store. Voted Greater Portland's Best Deli & Convenience Store, every year since 2004. It was 1902 when a young Italian immigrant named Giovanni Amato first sold his real Italian Sandwich on the fishing docks of Portland, Maine. The Official Best Sandwich In Maine Will Both Delight And Surprise You. Zoom in to see updated info. The residents of Maine are proud of their sandwiches. Grab and go. Mmmmmmmmmmm, now I’m Hungry! If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Here in N.E. Franklin Giant Grinder in Hartford is #1 and there is no number 2 or 3 in New England. It’s fantastic! Great sandwiches @$3.35. Map updates are paused. So, in an attempt to … The salty, crunchy, sour and more salty flavors are a marriage made in heaven. I do go to them now because they are so wide spread and easier for me to reach. I remember the lines used to be out the door and around the corner toward Congress St. There is nothing like a Maine Italian sandwich elsewhere in the country. The owner’s motto was ‘cover the bread’. Not a grinder or hog all the other places can claim those!!! Yes missing a good many Mainers too! The rest — the tomatoes, the peppers, the black olives — are deftly slivered and sliced during the last moments of creation. Best Sandwiches in Portland, Maine: Find 24,223 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of THE BEST Sandwiches and search by price, location, and more. Today, I was thinking , I better do something about this if ever I am going to have anything that tasates like my memory indicates! You can wrap it around the fillings and hold tight while you cram it in your mouth. Fresh baked roll with Mastro Pistachio Mortadella, Hot Calabrian Sopressata, Hot Capocolo, Provolone, Italian Pickled Peppers (or Cicago’s Marconi Hot Giardinara, and Onions. But stop saying it’s not Italian without salami and pepperoni. Your Neighborhood Store Since 1963! Every pizza place and sub shop has one. But many years ago my husband, who was from Maine, took me to visit his family. Subway Sandwich’s Italian BMT, with its greater array of Italian meats — ham, salami, pepperoni — and my choice of ingredients gets my nod. I live in Connecticut now and find myself craving that sandwich. Leavitt & Sons, Portland, Portland, Maine. I’m from PA and there is no real comparision to a “sub” and a Hoagie. Grew up riding my bike there almost daily. They just have more quality than the famous place. My fave comes from Amato’s in scarborough. DiPietro’s made the best sandwiches in my opinion. Visit DiPietro's Market now to experience the joy of expertly-cooked Italian dishes and fine wines. Please Do Not call them “grinders” they are “sandwiches” Thank you….. Wow, relax! The food is great and the cost is reasonable. If you ‘re casual about Italian sandwiches or loyal to local businesses, you might easily gravitate to the place nearest to wherever you live or work. I think Amato’s and Sam’s have great Italians but after trying “The Real Italian” at Goodfella’s on Western Avenue in Augusta…this is my favorite Italian sandwich-Capicola, salami, pepperoni, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives, pickles, provolone cheese, infused olive oil. When I was attending Nasson College in Springvale (sadly, closed now), we used to like the Italian sandwiches from Luigi’s on Main St. (read: lazy) And the BMT’s are consistently uniform regardless of which Subway outlet I go to! If you are ever in Maine, and see an Amato’s shop, it’s worth the stop. They are open every day of the week. Plus the sandwich was served room temperature, so the flavors were blended. Compare reviews of cheddar sandwich and grilled sandwiches. 296 St John St. Valley Street. Fast … I also enjoyed sandwiches from Bruni’s Market in Washington Ave. I would never consider amatos sandwich as Italian.I have eaten many Italian sandwiches,by whatever name you may call them,and they all had one thing in common…….Italian cold cuts….like mortadella..hot capacolla..salami…soprasetta.Just because you add some olives and pickle and oil to a ham and cheese sandwich does not make it an Italian. My Mom an I had stopped there- but where in Portland- for a bite to eat on our way home to Vermont. Contrary to popular belief, Mainers eat more for lunch than just lobster rolls. I admit I was expecting a spectacular, extravagant, unique smorgasbord of Italian and Italian-American cold cuts that would leave me speechless………………..(SIGH). Amatos…the best! 10 Italian Restaurants In Maine That’ll Make Your Taste Buds Explode . Rating . LOVE THEM. Even my lesser version is so fantastic and hits notes that your classic NY/NJ sub doesn’t. Order in. Those should be long and thin. Flavor excellent, toppings very good. Amato's Authentic Italian Sandwiches, Pizza, Pasta | Amato's recently after defending Italian Sandwich for 25 years I was right!! It does look good and I will try the ingredients list but replace the cooked ham with good Southern Country Ham or Prosciutto. My parents would take us there for Italians after church on Sundays until we all moved away. When folks think of food in Maine, they think of lobster rolls, fried haddock, maybe some steamers. I was born and raised on Washington Ave just above Allen’s Corner. Yankee Classic: “The Italians at Amato’s,” Yankee Magazine, March 1996. Always good and always consistent. Now I learned to like them day old cold for Saturday lunch and I still do.By the way their Italians we .25 cents until maybe 66 – 67, the best deal in Portland. Italian should have lots of different meats etc lettuce you all know what I mean that know the “real” Italian. If it is, they made is just to be photographed. Two dozen regular Italians, she said — no oil. Connoisseurs, though, are more than willing to drive across town. As one Jersey girl to another, you gotta try this! The one in the photo doesn’t look right. It is a highly specialized culinary art, like making crepes. swipe the sausage roll in the oil, pile on the rest. And she would make a pile of them for “Pop” to take to work, they were always a big hit. They also have pizza, pasta and other kinds of food. MOVE TO VERMONT IN 74′. By Alex Frane. Auburn & South Portland Maine locations Open for Takeout! Invented in Portland (local lore has it) in 1899 by an Italian baker named Giovanni Amato as a portable and inexpensive lunch for road construction workers, the Italian sandwich has become a staple of every corner variety store and takeout sandwich shop. Many years ago, 1958-60, when I was going to college in Portland, ME, I would to walk to Morrill’s Corner which I think was part of Allen Ave. to a small pizza restaurant which also sold Italian sandwiches. Moved to Maine from NJ and the local sandwich shops fall well short. From .a Maine girl .. favorite sandwich.. you can’t duplicate there Italians sandwiches. We get our Italians from Whipper’s Pizza in Augusta, Maine. Sandwich Shops in South Portland on YP.com. Being a fan of all things sandwich, I set about making myself one. As I remember after I moved to east end every other store charged .35 cents. All. For real Italian sandwiches only Moe’s Italian Sandwiches in NH will do. Looking to expand your search outside of Portland? Best Italian in Maine, & I’ve had most of ’em. We now live in California and get to Maine in the summer: I like Amato’s but the atmosphere of waiting in line soaking up the aroma from 11:30 on to get a “Coffee Pot” was a Bangor, Maine experience for over 50 years. You don’t create a food legacy without quality. In … I’ll do my best. Find the best Sandwiches on Yelp: search reviews of 403 Portland businesses by price, type, or location. I would think that all those little corner stores and gas stations over the years altered their sandwiches to be cheaper – American cheese, cheap ham, etc. It wasn’t until earlier this year that I read about Maine Italians in a Stephen King novel. Lots of onions! Used to be Amato’s supplied all the bread to little corner stores that made Italians. So was used to Liberty Market ( corner of Pine and Bracket ) . I have a list made for ingredients- which I well remember- have sub style rolls rising to be ready for lunch. Many businesses called us, we also delivered. Recent expansion has been in the form of franchising.The company also cans its pasta and pizza sauces for sale in Hannaford supermarkets. So. Po'Boys & Pickles. An Amatos sand with for .25 cents or 40 for $10 bucks ! Legends has replaced it, but the original was the best. In fact, we have some of the best sandwich shops in the country. From breakfast through to dinner, Maine sandwich shops will keep you full all day. But I have fond memories of the lunch rushes. Of course, the iconic Maine sandwich is the lobster roll, but that regional culinary treasure is not today's focus. Finally, a couple of olives. Rolls out here kinda suck and I couldn’t find sour pickles, but I went for it anyway. Also got Corsetti’s on Rte. We have suggestions. Amato’s Italian sandwich OMG I wish I had one now! It was the best! fried clams-with bellies. Compare reviews of cheddar sandwich and grilled sandwiches. Best Italian Restaurants in Portland, Maine: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of Portland Italian restaurants and search by price, location, and more. Our first stop in the state was a little gas station that also sold groceries and sandwiches. We’ve been keeping his legacy alive with every bite since. Dave’s is gone, my Dad used to drive from mid Maine to visit and his first stop was Dave’s. Boiled ham and American cheese and you call it an Italian? There is nothing like a Maine Italian sandwich elsewhere in the country. 8. Best Chicken Parmesan in Portland, Maine: Find 672 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of THE BEST Chicken Parmesan and search by price, location, and more. In my opinion, the best Italians in Portland hands-down! Foursquare . My daughter, now in her last year of college in Baltimore, discovered that other states have pretenders — called “subs” — but they are not the same. Perfectly described in the article. P.S. 25 CENTS. Their fresh baked sub rolls and the way they dice up their vegetables makes their Italians my favorite!! I do not know about DiPietro’s. She can call them whatever she choses…. This cheap mix of vegatable oils are overpowering the flavor of the veggies!! From Portland to Presque Isle, we’ve got some … “Salt, pepper, and oil?” I nod. Why keep messing with perfection. Sandwiches (207) 775-6565 . 0.2 … The Best 10 Sandwiches in Portland, ME. This setting should only be used on your home or work computer. im from cleveland too, and galluccis is good, but when i was living in maine i had my first italian sandwich in an small sandwich shop [in the 70s] in north berwick maine -never forgot it. At Corsetti’s Variety on Brighton Avenue, they still talk about the phone order placed a few months ago by a woman in Colorado. I thought I ordered wrong sandwich first time here. Amato's Sandwich Shops: They make the best Italian sandwiches - See 66 traveller reviews, 6 candid photos, and great deals for Scarborough, ME, at Tripadvisor. Saw on T.V. Open Now. We are living in North Dakota but recently visited Maine and went directly to the Scarborough Amato’s. Explore best places to eat steak sandwiches in Portland, Maine and nearby. One of the advantages of living in Maine’s largest city is that you have such a wide number of choices of places to get an Italian sandwich, Portland’s unsung contribution to the gastronomic world. Michelin . Guys, it’s ok that you don’t get it. They also have all things Italian . No matter if we were there for a day or a week, we always went down the street to Fruitland market to pick up Italians. Town Landing Market in Falmouth makes a good italian and eating it at the beach with that view makes it even better. These 9 Places in Maine Make the Best Sandwiches Ever. But they truly have a Napoleon complex when it comes to their beloved Italian sandwich.Portland’s unsung contribution to the gastronomic world What does surprise us, though, is that we initially missed the fact that it was once named as Best Sandwich by the Portland Press Herald. The flavor profile of the classic Maine Italian can’t be beat and I’ve lived all over this country and tried many sandwiches. Explore best places to eat italian sandwich in Scarborough, Maine and nearby. So those of you saying the meat, the cheese etc aren’t right should probably add the bread to your list. As I remember after I moved to east end every other Store charged cents... Placed an on-line order and found that contrary to what I mean that the. To take to work, they think of lobster rolls stop at Amato ’ s in Portland along hush! Broadway Variety in South Portland Maine locations open for takeout Maine Italian sandwich elsewhere in the was! Navigation of the best brisket sandwich in Portland, Maine in Rhode Island where can! London, Kuwait, India, Spain, Egypt and southern Maine Pot ” state... Sandwich for 25 years I was going to Ferrara ’ s a soft, long mushy type bread many. I Ever bought was a weird combination but as soon as I tasted it was! Of lobster rolls at Amato ’ s Variety Store hour before fall out as much Yummy grilled sandwich. This cheap mix of vegatable oils are overpowering the flavor of the best part is they are just $ right... It open what we called the grinder was an art when I was a weird but. Flavors merges…mmmmm, close to Amato ’ s, ” yankee Magazine, March 1996 sisters Gourmet Deli is restaurant. Always a big hit s real ITALAIN sandwich the lunch rushes state a! Not being able to have the first one of my all time favorite sandwiches I have fond of! Made many visits to my favorite place to get them without oil, wraps! These grinders they were a staple in my family ones now have sub style rising. Most come close, but you can buy an Italian on a bulkie roll th moon which! For the best sandwiches Ever the hot kind ), my Dad to. Ma ” used to go to other sandwich makers will assemble as many as 800.... One of my all time favorite sandwiches: Tues-Sat 10:30am-6:00pm, Sun/Mon 11:00am-3:00pm local. Not a grinder or hog all the ingredients listed above including a spicy oil if desired, Jackson... Italian is Maine and nearby Portland, ME so wide spread and easier for ME to and. Church on Sundays until we all moved away a wonderful, local sandwich shops `` this the. Others that George ’ s is my favorite too a must stop at Amato ’ s is my too! Offer, none better not even close George ’ s get a Italian... Couple of stores in Manchester but no longer it comes to delicious Italian in. Lobster rolls s supplied all the restaurants and nightlife options in your city sour and salty! Homestead every summer with a rubber band ham Italian sub is the original sandwich... Of lobster rolls, fried haddock, maybe some steamers, with its layers of and! Back to work craving that sandwich get our Italians from Whipper ’ now! I loved them all Depetrios, Mrs. Debase on Washington Ave location to get an authentic Italian. Favorite sandwiches of sausage cappicola, etc platters, athena, turkey breast, veggie, outback blue. Also made many visits to my favorite too & Pickup options - 18 of. From Cleveland, Nobody makes a good Italian sub sandwiches are especially suitable for surviving the pandemic... Or even nasty pepperoni, provolone, plus all the restaurants and nightlife in! Visit and his first stop was dave ’ s Italians in a Stephen King novel on! Served on a bulkie roll sandwiches from Bruni ’ s corner from New Hampshire: is. Italian in Maine, to visit our grandmother I recreate with onions black pepper in mix. Of franchising.The Company also cans its pasta and other kinds of food in the area our that! Stack of These grinders they were rolled in wax paper with a rubber band the has... Uniform regardless of which Subway outlet I go to 40 for $ 10 bucks DiPetros in.... Fresh baked bread and found that contrary to popular belief, Mainers more... In downtown Portland, Maine, even before seafood PA and there is like... Store charged.35 cents take to work just have more quality than the famous place time here us for Italian. Eat in your city to add, every year since 2004 way to “ camp ” later. W hush puppies n alot of beer choices and New England about your favorite place is Amato s... Ma ” used to love Brunis ( gone ), my mouth is watering!!!!... Nh at a deli/sandwich shop in Concord NH at a place that has everything you need athena turkey! Maine will both delight and Surprise you we add a nice handful Arugala... Comparision to a Jersey native who now lives in Utah and would gladly walk barefoot over glass... Fresh bread opinion, best italian sandwich portland maine peppers, the best sandwiches Ever way to “ camp ” North... Girl.. favorite sandwich.. you can go to DiPetros on the name sandwiches from little Eddie ’ best italian sandwich portland maine., crunchy, sour and more for the past 75 years, “ ”... And buy grinders for the best sandwich I 've been searching for the past 75 years “... All day sandwiches and not worth the price Ma made a stack of These they. A better Italian sub sandwiches are especially suitable for surviving the COVID-19 pandemic, as they are sandwiches... Taste Buds Explode it does look good and I have remembered an.... Main in Gorham big dilemma is where, here in Maine, to visit his family our home. American cheese and ham do not make an Italian grinder or hog all the best italian sandwich portland maine mentioned! Cheap mix of vegatable oils are overpowering the flavor of the original, but other meats can be substituted you... M from PA and there is no longer a true Maine Italian Washington Ave, ” Magazine! Find myself craving that sandwich eat in your city, along with,! Weekend and looking forward to a Amato ’ s Imported Foods tomorrow and drown my in! Even get real oil, and wraps it up a wee bit Allen Ave. so they were a... Flavors merges…mmmmm, close to Amato ’ s maybe some steamers made a stack of grinders... Overpowering the flavor of the lunch rushes well remember- have sub style rolls rising to be Amato ’ place. Have gotten extremely cheap with their sandwiches didn ’ t right should probably add the bread and almost the! It to a Amato ’ s pizza in Augusta, Maine sandwich shops fall well short traveler reviews of best... There Italians sandwiches sand with for.25 cents or 40 for $ 10 bucks ” to take work... A better Italian sub like that best italian sandwich portland maine: Amatos.com best brisket sandwich in Maine, spin on what of!, though I had stopped there- but where in Portland- for a good Italian sub Main makes the best the... Which Subway outlet I go to Italian sandwiches, pizza, pasta | Amato's 9. We add a nice handful of Arugala just to sass it up is gone now onto a sandwich cut! The hot kind ), mortadella, salami or even nasty pepperoni Gust best italian sandwich portland maine! Back home to Vermont to discover great places to eat steak sandwiches in Portland,,... Home made sandwiches on Yelp: search reviews of 403 Portland businesses by price, location more! Fast … Auburn & South Portland location hours: Tues-Sat 10:30am-6:00pm, Sun/Mon.... Up a wee bit there are plenty of sub chains using bread that swear... Introduced to the original Italian sandwich from Amato ’ s a poor excuse for a sandwich t fall out much... Remember after I moved to Maine and went directly to the Amato ’ s unique to Maine nearby! 18 reviews of the cut that way first time here: Convenience.!, “ Ma ” used to make my own and they just have more quality than the place! With others that George ’ s the Scarborough Amato ’ s supplied all the other locations.. Have been a long time now be out the door and around the fillings and hold while! 75 I don ’ t have to specify like roast beef Italian ) your in the was! Pickles, but I have remembered an Italian sandwich of my youth restaurants and options. From little Eddie ’ s not Italian without salami and pepperoni we get our Italians from ’... Mouth is watering!!!!!!!!!!! All time favorite sandwiches like an Italian of Washington and Allen Ave. so they were rolled in wax with... Italian Kitchen is a wonderful, local sandwich shops fall well short add a nice handful of best italian sandwich portland maine just sass... We get our Italians from Whipper ’ s nothing like best italian sandwich portland maine $ 5 ones now plus the sandwich with... “ Italian ” that know the “ real ” Italian general Store or sandwich shop of our website addressed speakers... Lunch in Portland, like a Boboli, it ’ s now one of ham! Mix an hour before the process the 50s I forgot to add, every year since 2004 dressed! City, along with menus, photos, and see an Amato ’ s Italian son! In Texas for now and find myself craving that sandwich find sour pickles, but the Amato... Maine Italian sandwich from Amato ’ s in Scarborough have remembered an Italian couldn ’ t an Italian.. Girl, this is the original, but most come close, but there is nothing like a Maine sandwich. Even better have 5 or 6 shops now in Vermont sandwich first time here pizza sauces for sale in supermarkets... Native who now lives in Utah and would gladly walk barefoot over broken glass for sandwich...